"Raising the bar" on modules, how to improveThe basic concept of modules is interchangability and ease to set up and tear down a layout.A lot has changed since the first Zbend modules.The ZoCal group has set up modules that have a mainline length of 10 scale miles.I've got some observations on where I think we can improve. In the sections below I describe how "we" (ZoCal) does it, and some personal suggestions on how we could improve.Note: the simple stuff is first, and the more complicated stuff follows. My goal is to do the easy/simple stuff first and then get into the more complex/controversial issues.I'm trying to use 4 parts to each "topic"Zocal implementation - overview of what we do that is different or "beyond" the Zbend standardIssues - what issues we have, things to improveHow to improve - suggestions and ideas on how to improveDetails - more in-depth information. Module legsZocal implementationOne large improvement has been the standardization of the legs for modules. Threaded knobs are used to affix the leg to the module and a threaded insert is in the module side. Simple, quick, effective. All legs are also equipped with leveling feet.IssuesMy only issue where I think we can improve comes from experience at shows: Missing knobs. The knobs are sometimes left in the legs, sometimes in the modules, and sometimes in a bag or box somewhere. A good solution will make it so we don't waste time looking around for the knobs.How to improveI was thinking of putting a circlip on the threaded shaft of the knob to make the knob captive. That solves the loss issue for sure, but has other issues, hard to stack the legs, and harder to attach the legs to the modules. (The leg fits in so closely, you just need the threads "peeking out" of the leg to get into the threaded insert.Jeff Thompson came up with a simple, elegant suggestion, drill a lengthwise hole in the top of the leg to store the knob. Now they can be bundled up in groups, stacked neatly (since the knob is about the same diameter as the leg) and when stacked up, it's clear if a knob is missing from the "forest" of legs.Details on the implementation:Need to fill in: leg size:xx" hole drilled xx" from the tophole drilled in top to store knobleveling foot is xx" longknob specsModule joining / alignmentZocal implementationWe use threaded knobs. We found bolts too much work, need a wrench. Wing nuts could not get enough pressure by hand. We have found that holes closer to the top of the module result in better module alignment.IssuesBiggest issue is that nothing lines up! Seriously there's a number of factors here. The Zbend standard has a good "core" idea of measuring from the center of the module, but from a practical aspect, when modules are built this way, then you have 2 measurements from the center to align tracks, where the real issue is that all 4 tracks need to be aligned to each other, not a center.Another issue is that the holes to join modules are not in the right place to allow the tracks to be aligned.A final issue is that since there are inaccuracies everywhere, the holes need to be large enough to have some "give" when aligning, and some are too small for the newer, larger diameter threaded knobs we are using.How to improveThe first thing that makes sense is get the holes and the tracks all in the proper relationship. We need a template that can easily and accurately point out any problems.Details on the Implementation: Module electrical debugging: main linesZocal implementationdescribe the current mounting, specs, using knobsIssuesHow to improve
Module Accessories / ImprovementsDrawers for modules:Don Fedjur makes some killer drawers that fit onto modules. Throttle holders:New Rail Models http://www.newrailmodels.com/Universal.htm makes a nice holder for the NCE and other throttles. They list at $12 each, and they can also be bought in 3 and 10 packs, getting the price down to about $8 each. I'm not aware of anyone else making these. They are ok, but I wish I could find something "deeper" and something that would work better to hook it on my belt.
Z Scale Modules(remember: links to sub-pages at the bottom of this page)click to jump to the bottom ZoCal notes:NCE wireless throttle addresses 4 greg e5 greg e8 Chuck G11 Henri S15 David LWhy modules?The concept of modules, not only for clubs and displays, but as a layout you can set up at home is great.portabilityshare with otherschange track planscan be stored away in a small spacePlease note that I have taken a lot of following from emails, so if you see some familiar sentences, I apologize for the plagiarism! It's for the common good!Module standards/specifications:Most people use the Z-Bend Track standard (ZBT) as a basis for their modules. Apparently the original site is gone, but the PDF of th estandard is hosted here: http://www.ztrack.com/resources/Z-Bend_Track_Manual_2004.pdf The idea is that modules have at least 2 tracks on the outer edge of a 24" wide module. The tracks are located at a standard offset from the center of the module, 9" and 10", so making a wider module will still allow them to mate. The length can be anything. You can also have curved modules, or 45 degree or 90 degree.This standard has not been improved or updated since 2004. There's improvements that many people make that don't violate the standard, but it really should be updated.Basic dimensions:The Z-Bend manual tends to "think straight", but as long as the specification that the tracks are 9" & 10" from the module center line (at the ends of the module) is met, the tracks can curve in between. Also the standard tends to focus on straight, rectangular modules, more variation is OK."Module" height is actually supposed to be written as "top of track" height. The height should be 50 inches. This is higher than most other scales, but it works well because Z is smaller. The height is also convenient for working on the modules.The modules without legs are typically 5" high.Physically connecting modules:The modules have track that should stop 2-1/8" from the end of the module. Marklin expandable track sections are used to connect the track between modules. The standards call for where the joiners are and were written before MTL track. In the construction pages I will address this.Electrically connecting modules:The standard calls for four DB25 connector, one at each "mainline" connection, remember you have two double track mainlines per module. These connectors are used on old serial ports on computers, two rows of pins, 25 total.While not designed for high current, groups of 3 pins are used together to increase current handling capability. The connector basically carries the inner and outer mainline power. There are other pins and uses, but this is the basic way power is transmitted."Deviation" from the ZBT standardPlease note that the Z-bend standards were written before MT (Micro Trains) and Rokohan track was available.Also note that no one has revised them to benefit from experience gained since they were written.My opinions are based on what I have seen work and learning from people who run modules very successfully.Joiners for the expansion tracks at the ends of the module:I suggest using the MT joiners (part number 958 [990 40 000] ). They fit the wider rail base of MTL flex and clamp tightly on all three manufacturer's rail web. Some like the Peco type but some people find them extremely loose and only hold on the rail base. Märklin joiners (8954 or 6705) should be avoided at all costs. They are very thin metal, bend easily and will quickly wear out which means loose, damaged, etc. In addition, they will NOT fit on Micro-Trains flex track as the MTL rail base as about .008" wider than Märklin's. The MTL track will spread the Märklin joiners open too far.ZBT standards call for rail joiners on the module tracks, none on the expansion tracks. My experience has shown that the joiners get damaged, and unless you solder them on (read next paragraph), you cannot guarantee where they stay. I just let them stay where they want, and keep spare joiners on hand. Replace them when they get damaged.From experience, I recommend that the joiners are NOT soldered on. By all means, do NOT use CA glue either! First, very few people can solder joiners without melting the track. When (not if, WHEN) joiners get damaged, it's much harder to remove one that is soldered on. Even if you get it off without damage, you still have to contend with solder left over on the rail, and the new joiner will not sit in place properly. It's just a mess. Get a box of joiners.In some cases, you actually want to not have metal joiners on the connector tracks, and might use insulated joiners. This helps debugging electrical problems and also facilitates using independent power blocks using their own circuit protection. More on this in other sections.If you really want to affix the joiners, it's much safer and easier to do it to the expansion track. You can pull the rails completely out of the expansion track to solder with no danger of melting anything. Also, you can glue the insulated joiners on them with no ill effects. (read more elsewhere about not using the expansion tracks to conduct power and also modifying expansion tracks for better performance)Roadbed preparation:The basic goal is, where the expansion track is, the roadbed or ballast must clear the expansion track; give yourself at least 1mm of clearance. This minimizes bowing or humps/dips between modules. Even though it might not look as nice, if the expansion tracks are bowing up, you can tap them several times to get them level. With no space underneath, you cannot "tweak" the expansion tracks.(read elsewhere on my methods of preparing the expansion tracks.)
Marklin TrackHere's a table of Marklin part numbers. If you find any errors or have something to add, please let me know.Part #TypeLength mmLength inchesAdditional 8500 Straight110 mm length4-3/8" 8503 Straight55 mm length2-3/16" 8504 Straight25 mm length1" 8505 Straight220 mm length8-13/16" 8506 Straight108.6 mm length4-5/16" 8507 Straight (matches length of 8559 & 8560)112.8 mm length4-7/16" 8510 Curve145 mm radius / 45º arc5-3/4" / 45º arc1/8th circle 8520 Curve195 mm radius / 45º arc7-11/16" / 45º arc1/8th circle 8521 Curve195 mm radius / 30º arc7-11/16" / 30º arc1/12th circle 8529 Curved circuit track195 mm radius / 30º arc7-11/16" / 30º arcSee 8589 below 8530 Curved220 mm radius / 45º arc8-11/16" / 45º arc45º arc, 1/8th circle 8531 Curved220 mm radius / 30º arc8-11/16" / 30º arc30º arc, 1/12th circle 8539 Curved circuit track220 mm radius / 30º arc8-11/16" / 30º arcSee 8589 below 8559 Crossing112.8 mm / 13º crossing4-7/16" / 13ºThere are 2 versions of this 8560 Double Slip Remote112.8 mm long / 323 mm closure radius4-7/16" long / 12-3/4" closure radiusFrog angle 185 8561L 8561R With R or L suffix, remote turnout set of 1 each left and right Now obsolete, replaced by 8562, 8563, same spec 8562 Turnout Left Remote112.8mm long4-7/16" / 13ºFrog angle 13º 8563 Turnout Right Remote112.8mm long4-7/16" / 13ºFrog angle 13º 8564L 8564R With R or L suffix, manual turnout, set of 1 each left and right Now obsolete, replaced by 8565, 8566, same specs 8565 Turnout Left Manual112.8mm long4-7/16" / 13ºFrog angle 13º 8566 Turnout Right Manual112.8mm long4-7/16" / 13ºFrog angle 13º 8567L 8567R With R or L suffix, curved remote turnout set of 1 each left and right Now obsolete, replaced by 8568, 8569, same specs 8568 Turnout Curved Left Remote112.8mm long, 220 and 195 mm radius4-7/16" long / 8-11/16" and 7-11/16" radiusFrog angle 13º 8569 Turnout Curved Right Remote112.8mm long, 220 and 195 mm radius4-7/16" long / 8-11/16" and 7-11/16" radius Frog angle 13º 8587 straight uncoupler track 8588 straight isolating track 55? 8589 straight circuit track 8590 straight feeder track 8591 curved track (turnout curve) 8592 expansion track 100-120 3-15/16” to 4-3/4” 8594 straight track ?? 8931 bumper track 8954 rail joiners 8991 track bumper? 8993 reverse loop set 8997 extension set for turntable